I keep making the same mistake. Somewhere I will read a review or an enthusiastic mention of a book, and think, "Hmm, that's right up my alley!" So I buy it – sometimes as hard copy, sometimes as an e-book – and then stop reading it somewhere around page 50. It seems my alley is never quite where I thought it was, or goes where I thought it did. But, being a fool for a nice book, if it's a pretty thing it will stay on my shelves, partly read, perhaps to be given a second or even a third chance. As a consequence, my shelves hold rather too many pretty, part-read books that I will never get around to re-reading.
A recent example of this has been To Photograph Is To Learn How To Die: an essay with digressions, by Tim Carpenter. Great title! A play, as I'm sure you realise, on Montaigne: "To philosophise is to learn how to die". It comes with solid recommendations, too; ecstatic rear cover blurbs by photographers Rebecca Norris Webb, Alec Soth, Terri Weifenbach, and Raymond Meeks, all of whom feature on my bookshelves, fully read, multiple times, if one can be said to have "read" a photo-book. Here's Ray Meeks:
This is a book that rewards those who defiantly embrace the idiosyncrasies and shortcomings that lend us our essential individuality while sharing in an abiding love for this flawed world.
Hey, that's me! Or, at least, I thought it was. I really wanted to like this book. I was predisposed to like it, and perhaps – as per Rebecca Norris Webb's endorsement – even to "keep the book on my bedside table near the poems of Emily Dickinson and Tomas Tranströmer, for those sleepless nights when a little light – or enlightenment – is needed".
However, the fact that I do not have a bedside table, and have never felt the need to read either Dickinson or Tranströmer (seriously?) in the middle of the night should probably have tipped me off. But in my mind, at least, I can be at least as pretentious serious as the next serious person. I can imagine being the sort of person who reaches for poetic comfort reading at 3 am, but I don't think my partner would want to share a bed with that person. It's bad enough that I have to get up for a pee two or three times a night.
Make no mistake, TPITLHTD is a very pretty book, as published by The Ice Plant. It's a small but substantial paperback (240 4½" x 6½" pages), bound in actual untrimmed "gatherings" (i.e. not "perfect" bound, one of the book trade's worst crimes against bibliophilia), beautifully designed and typeset on good-quality, tactile paper. It's even printed in three colours: black for the main text, blue for the "digressions" mentioned in the subtitle, and orange for the extensive quotations. As Tim Carpenter says:
You could return to the stuff in blue and orange after reading the core theme, or take the slow road and digest it all in sequence. I suggest the latter approach, but it's up to you.
But its prettiness is all that has saved it from being hurled across the room multiple times.
Why? Because this is a classic example of an idea that would comfortably fit on one side of a sheet of A4 paper which has been inflated to fill a book. It is almost entirely made up of digressions into the thoughts of other writers – philosophers, poets, photographers, novelists, critics – and quotations from them. It's like reading someone's busy first draft of an academic thesis before their supervisor has said, "Please, spare me: you can drop at least half of these superfluous namedrops". The interlocking maze of black, orange, and blue text looks enticing, but – like any maze – is just a way of gamifying frustration. Some of the digressions go on for several pages. Please, Tim, I don't care about Heidegger! And I finished with the likes of Lionel Trilling and Harold Bloom decades ago! FFS just get to the point! Which is? (No, nothing to do with witches, to steal a line from Radio 4's The Naked Week):
That's really all we can ever do: try to figure out how to be of use, to ourselves and to others, within our limitations, by continuously choosing well between the worthy and the not.
Or, in the famous words he quotes from Montaigne:
Your life's continual task is to build your death.
That's it? Did I say one side of A4? I was exaggerating: a postcard would do the job, once stripped of all the earnest Master's dissertation apparatus.
It bothers me that photographers like Meeks or Soth would read such a work and endorse it quite so enthusiastically. I have to assume they have actually read it. Call me a cynic, but I’d take some persuading that either of them knew of, let alone had read most of the various witnesses called to the stand by Tim Carpenter, never mind the validity of the case he builds upon their testimony. As I have had cause to remark before, those with a talent for art would do well to stay in their lane when it comes to philosophy and poetics (and vice versa, of course).
I will keep the book, though. The hundreds of quotations are fun to dip into, and it will doubtless become a sought-after classic. Sought after, that is, by people who, like me, will have been seduced by the idea of it, but will end up either throwing it across the room or adding it to their own collection of partly-read curiosities.
Such encounters are useful, though, in that they reinforce the self-knowledge that I am not, at bottom, a Serious Person. Serious People do have bedside tables heaped with Serious Books, do care about Heidegger, and do enjoy the ludic impenetrability and intertextuality of post-modern writing. Or so I believe. I imagine they're not much fun to live with, although in small doses they do make interesting friends. As Tim Carpenter says, it's important to acknowledge our limitations. It's why I abandoned the prospect of an academic career, and yet – in order to maintain an enjoyable proximity to all that solemn seriousness without having to endure a lifelong immersion in it – became an academic librarian.
In fact, I am by training a jobbing cataloguer. If you agree with Samuel Johnson that a lexicographer is a "harmless drudge", then I'm not sure what self-deprecatory term describes a mere lister and classifier of books. However, this line of work does lead to a certain hyper-awareness of the physicality and "bookiness" of books, as well as endowing you with a navigator's grasp of the map of the whole of human knowledge. The humble wisdom of the cataloguer lies in knowing that something exists and where it can be found, which is quite often a lot more useful to a lot more people than actually having read it yourself. Johnson again:
Knowledge is of two kinds. We know a subject ourselves, or we know where we can find information upon it. When we enquire into any subject, the first thing we have to do is to know what books have treated of it. This leads us to look at catalogues, and at the backs of books in libraries.
Happy to be of service, Sam, one harmless drudge to another. Of course, I have never actually read Boswell's Life of Johnson, the source of this quotation, but... (I think you can see where this is going).
In the end, I prefer these three perfect minutes of K.D. Lang's song "Simple" to a lifetime of head-scratching over Nazi-adjacent M. Heidegger's Being and Time, and I'm pretty confident that, when my time comes to stop being, I will have "chosen well between the worthy and the not":
Photography is simple, too, and will not elude us, unless we encumber it needlessly with philosophy. To photograph is to make pictures of or (my preference) from what is really there; to photograph is to learn how to see what is really there. AFAIK nobody has ever needed to learn how to die, but you can learn how to die well, I suppose; you just need to hope you will get the chance to put your learning into practice.
More than his black-print argument – which I found annoyingly couched in postgraduate-style hedging, defining, and jargonising, and finally abandoned at page 81 – I enjoyed the many orange-print quotations extracted from Tim Carpenter's clearly voracious appetite for reading that he cites along the circuitous way through the multi-coloured maze to (what I assume to be) his surprisingly unsurprising conclusions. I like this one, for example, from American photographer Robert Adams:
The point of art has never been to make something synonymous with life, however, but to make something of reduced complexity that is nonetheless analogous to life and can thereby clarify it.
(from Beauty in Photography, 1981)
Yep, learn how to see what is really there, and make a picture from it. That's another postcard right there, I reckon.





No comments:
Post a Comment