Tuesday, 17 November 2026

A Multi-Coloured Maze


I keep making the same mistake. Somewhere I will read a review or an enthusiastic mention of a book, and think, "Hmm, that's right up my alley!" So I buy it – sometimes as hard copy, sometimes as an e-book – and then stop reading it somewhere around page 50. It seems my alley is never quite where I thought it was, or goes where I thought it did. But, being a fool for a nice book, if it's a pretty thing it will stay on my shelves, partly read, perhaps to be given a second or even a third chance. As a consequence, my shelves hold rather too many pretty, part-read books that I will never get around to re-reading.

A recent example of this has been To Photograph Is To Learn How To Die: an essay with digressions, by Tim Carpenter. Great title! A play, as I'm sure you realise, on Montaigne: "To philosophise is to learn how to die". It comes with solid recommendations, too; ecstatic rear cover blurbs by photographers Rebecca Norris Webb, Alec Soth, Terri Weifenbach, and Raymond Meeks, all of whom feature on my bookshelves, fully read, multiple times, if one can be said to have "read" a photo-book. Here's Ray Meeks:

This is a book that rewards those who defiantly embrace the idiosyncrasies and shortcomings that lend us our essential individuality while sharing in an abiding love for this flawed world.

Hey, that's me! Or, at least, I thought it was. I really wanted to like this book. I was predisposed to like it, and perhaps – as per Rebecca Norris Webb's endorsement – even to "keep the book on my bedside table near the poems of Emily Dickinson and Tomas Tranströmer, for those sleepless nights when a little light – or enlightenment – is needed".

However, the fact that I do not have a bedside table, and have never felt the need to read either Dickinson or Tranströmer (seriously?) in the middle of the night should probably have tipped me off. But in my mind, at least, I can be at least as pretentious serious as the next serious person. I can imagine being the sort of person who reaches for poetic comfort reading at 3 am, but I don't think my partner would want to share a bed with that person. It's bad enough that I have to get up for a pee two or three times a night.

Make no mistake, TPITLHTD is a very pretty book, as published by The Ice Plant. It's a small but substantial paperback (240 4½" x 6½" pages), bound in actual untrimmed "gatherings" (i.e. not "perfect" bound, one of the book trade's worst crimes against bibliophilia), beautifully designed and typeset on good-quality, tactile paper. It's even printed in three colours: black for the main text, blue for the "digressions" mentioned in the subtitle, and orange for the extensive quotations. As Tim Carpenter says:

You could return to the stuff in blue and orange after reading the core theme, or take the slow road and digest it all in sequence. I suggest the latter approach, but it's up to you.

But its prettiness is all that has saved it from being hurled across the room multiple times.

"Digest"?!

Why? Because this is a classic example of an idea that would comfortably fit on one side of a sheet of A4 paper which has been inflated to fill a book. It is almost entirely made up of digressions into the thoughts of other writers – philosophers, poets, photographers, novelists, critics – and quotations from them. It's like reading someone's busy first draft of an academic thesis before their supervisor has said, "Please, spare me: you can drop at least half of these superfluous namedrops". The interlocking maze of black, orange, and blue text looks enticing, but – like any maze – is just a way of gamifying frustration. Some of the digressions go on for several pages. Please, Tim, I don't care about Heidegger! And I finished with the likes of Lionel Trilling and Harold Bloom decades ago! FFS just get to the point! Which is? (No, nothing to do with witches, to steal a line from Radio 4's The Naked Week):

That's really all we can ever do: try to figure out how to be of use, to ourselves and to others, within our limitations, by continuously choosing well between the worthy and the not.

Or, in the famous words he quotes from Montaigne:

Your life's continual task is to build your death.

That's it? Did I say one side of A4? I was exaggerating: a postcard would do the job, once stripped of all the earnest Master's dissertation apparatus.

It bothers me that photographers like Meeks or Soth would read such a work and endorse it quite so enthusiastically. I have to assume they have actually read it. Call me a cynic, but I’d take some persuading that either of them knew of, let alone had read most of the various witnesses called to the stand by Tim Carpenter, never mind the validity of the case he builds upon their testimony. As I have had cause to remark before, those with a talent for art would do well to stay in their lane when it comes to philosophy and poetics (and vice versa, of course).

I will keep the book, though. The hundreds of quotations are fun to dip into, and it will doubtless become a sought-after classic. Sought after, that is, by people who, like me, will have been seduced by the idea of it, but will end up either throwing it across the room or adding it to their own collection of partly-read curiosities.

Such encounters are useful, though, in that they reinforce the self-knowledge that I am not, at bottom, a Serious Person. Serious People do have bedside tables heaped with Serious Books, do care about Heidegger, and do enjoy the ludic impenetrability and intertextuality of post-modern writing. Or so I believe. I imagine they're not much fun to live with, although in small doses they do make interesting friends. As Tim Carpenter says, it's important to acknowledge our limitations. It's why I abandoned the prospect of an academic career, and yet – in order to maintain an enjoyable proximity to all that solemn seriousness without having to endure a lifelong immersion in it – became an academic librarian.

In fact, I am by training a jobbing cataloguer. If you agree with Samuel Johnson that a lexicographer is a "harmless drudge", then I'm not sure what self-deprecatory term describes a mere lister and classifier of books. However, this line of work does lead to a certain hyper-awareness of the physicality and "bookiness" of books, as well as endowing you with a navigator's grasp of the map of the whole of human knowledge. The humble wisdom of the cataloguer lies in knowing that something exists and where it can be found, which is quite often a lot more useful to a lot more people than actually having read it yourself. Johnson again:

Knowledge is of two kinds. We know a subject ourselves, or we know where we can find information upon it. When we enquire into any subject, the first thing we have to do is to know what books have treated of it. This leads us to look at catalogues, and at the backs of books in libraries.

Happy to be of service, Sam, one harmless drudge to another. Of course, I have never actually read Boswell's Life of Johnson, the source of this quotation, but... (I think you can see where this is going).

In the end, I prefer these three perfect minutes of K.D. Lang's song "Simple" to a lifetime of head-scratching over Nazi-adjacent M. Heidegger's Being and Time, and I'm pretty confident that, when my time comes to stop being, I will have "chosen well between the worthy and the not":

        I worship this tenacity and the beautiful struggle we're in
Love will not elude us, love is simple

Photography is simple, too, and will not elude us, unless we encumber it needlessly with philosophy. To photograph is to make pictures of or (my preference) from what is really there; to photograph is to learn how to see what is really there. AFAIK nobody has ever needed to learn how to die, but you can learn how to die well, I suppose; you just need to hope you will get the chance to put your learning into practice.

More than his black-print argument – which I found annoyingly couched in postgraduate-style hedging, defining, and jargonising, and finally abandoned at page 81 – I enjoyed the many orange-print quotations extracted from Tim Carpenter's clearly voracious appetite for reading that he cites along the circuitous way through the multi-coloured maze to (what I assume to be) his surprisingly unsurprising conclusions. I like this one, for example, from American photographer Robert Adams:

The point of art has never been to make something synonymous with life, however, but to make something of reduced complexity that is nonetheless analogous to life and can thereby clarify it. 
(from Beauty in Photography, 1981)

 Yep, learn how to see what is really there, and make a picture from it. That's another postcard right there, I reckon.

Wednesday, 11 November 2026

IANAL


There's an initialism you often see on social media, IANAL, which looks vaguely naughty, but stands for "I am not a lawyer". Given that IANAL is nonetheless generally followed by an opinion on some legal matter, it might equally well be IAABRL: "I am a barrack-room lawyer", defined as "a person who freely and confidently offers authoritative-sounding opinions, advice, or arguments on rules, policies, or legal matters without any formal legal training or qualifications". The term was originally British military slang for any soldier who claimed to know "King's Regulations" well enough to argue with NCOs and officers or advise fellow squaddies on their rights. However, I will be using IANAL in this post to indicate that "I am not a linguist". Although I suppose I might lay claim to being a barrack-room (bar-room?) linguist.

Of course, those of us who have studied a foreign language or two – in my case four (does Latin count? If so five, plus various bits and pieces that add up to a macaronic sixth) – and even those who simply have strong opinions about the rights and wrongs of their native tongue, are all would-be amateur linguists. Although the language interests of the latter generally centre on a few of their favourite language peeves. You'll know the sort of thing that is meant by a "peeve": split infinitives, "less" versus "fewer", gender pronoun wars, invasive Americanisms, and so on. But knowing your way around a few languages or having strong opinions on "correct" usage does not qualify anyone as a linguist, as such, linguistics being an entire field of scholarship and research in its own right. Although, naturally, that doesn't stop us having strong opinions and voicing them, just as we might on art or politics or anything else. What are blogs for, after all?

So, recently on a language-related blog that I read most days – one that is followed and commented on by a lively and intimidatingly well-informed posse of actual linguists – I was reading about the complaint (and lawsuit) of Lin King, a professional translator who has published an award-winning translation from Chinese into English, and who became aware of the uncompensated, unacknowledged use by a publisher of her own English text as the basis of further "translations" of the original book into other European languages. This is an example of so-called "relay" or "indirect" translation – translation from one language into another via an intermediary language – and has for a very long time been the way texts written in less well-known languages have been made available; the Bible is a prime example. 

How far this well-established practice is actually "illegal" is not the issue here (hey, IANAL I am not a lawyer...). No, what caught my eye was this quote:

I am often asked whether I identify more as a writer or translator. This is a false binary. Not all writers are translators, but all translators are writers. I chose, from the chaotic expanses of the English lexicon, every single word in Taiwan Travelogue. Shuāng-Zĭ [the original author] cannot read it, much like how I will not be able to read most translations of my novel when it is published next year. Our translators will write those books, not we.

Now, "Our translators will write those books, not we" strikes me as an extremely awkward piece of English. "Our translators" is, on the face of it, a bit strange – at first I took it for a typo for "other" – but what she means is "the future translators into other languages of both Shuāng-Zĭ's book and my own upcoming novel". OK... But what reads most oddly is that final "not we".

At least, it does to me. Which means I can crank up one of my own personal peeves. Stand back!

I think pretty much all native English speakers would have used "us" here, rather than "we", as in: "Our translators will write those books, not us". In fact, I also think I'd actually prefer "our translators will have written those books, not us". But "not we" would never feel like idiomatic English to me, in any context. Here's a curious thing, though: had she written "my translators", some of us would have said "not me", and some of us "not I", and both would pass the idiometer test. Which is interesting, no? Why this difference between singular and plural "first person" pronouns? Unfortunately, I don't know the answer: IANAL.

Now, I am admittedly a native speaker of British working-class English, albeit given a thorough makeover by further education. But, although I accept that to use "not I” here is perfectly idiomatic, I do find it excessively “proper”. Or perhaps it's that it feels inappropriately rhetorical, in a histrionic sort of way? It makes me think of Gloria Gaynor singing "I Will Survive": Oh no, not I!

Think of this scenario. Someone asks, "Who is that knocking at the door?" You could answer with one these two reponses: "It's me!" or "It is I!" I know which I would use. What you probably wouldn't say is "It's I!" In the end, such choices are all a matter of register or tone. [1]

Similarly, simple comparative contrasts show up the same issue. For example, "she is shorter than we" sounds ridiculous, doesn't it? But what about "she is shorter than me / than I" or "someone as ignorant of politics as me / as I"? Personally, I would never say or write "as I", and yet others would insist that this is more "correct". My presumption is that, like amputees sensing the presence of a missing limb, the "I" people sense the absence of an implicit verb – "she is shorter than I [am]" – whereas I do not. As Julie Andrews sings, "Me is a name I call myself"... Jack is taller than Jill; Jack is not taller than me.

It's interesting to see how other European languages handle this. For example, the French for "she is shorter than me" would always be elle est plus petite que moi; "moi" being the equivalent of "me" ("I" would be "je"). Whereas in German it would always be sie ist kleiner als ich, with "ich" being the equivalent of "I" ("me" would be "mich"). A quick sample on Google Translate shows that Italian and Norwegian are "me" languages, whereas Spanish and Swedish are "I" languages. It all seems pretty random, although a proper linguist could probably account for it. Sadly, I don't think any read this blog. Being British, of course, we hedge our bets and have it both ways; probably, like most British things, based on the shibboleths of social class.

But talking of social class, there are also other ways that "I" is often used that I would consider "wrong", or perhaps just annoying, given that any understandable utterance can't really be declared "wrong", linguistically-speaking.

An example I often hear would be something like: “They gave that job to John and I to do”. But if John is taken out of the picture, surely no-one would ever say, “They gave that job to I to do”, would they? Unless it was Talk Like A Pirate Day, obviously (September 19th, since you ask). [2] I suspect this odd "X and I" construction is a result of two possible factors. But bear in mind that IANAL...

First, class cringe. We're in toilet / lavatory / loo and sofa / settee territory here. Somehow, some aspiring folk from the British working and lower-middle classes seem to have gained the impression that "me" is in some way not as correct as "I", or is perhaps even a bit chavvy, like dropping your aitches, and they overcompensate. Others hear this particular usage from the mouths of those same aspiring folk, assume it must be "correct", and do the same. [3]

Second, the "X and I" construct (as in the former Queen's much parodied "my husband and I") seems to have achieved liberation from the constraints of grammar, and operates independently as a single unit. Would Her Maj ever have said, "The crowd threw rocks at my husband and I"? I don't think so, but I could be wrong. Whatever, the incompetent rock-throwers missed both her husband and she.

The thing is, though, most actual linguists tend to be "descriptive" in their approach, not "prescriptive". If people split their infinitives (a daft concept in the first place), or put up signs at supermarket checkouts for "five items or less", or now think "forensic" means "scientific investigation of crime scenes" rather than "for use in a court of law", then that's just language in the process of changing, as it will, not precious rules being broken by annoying, know-nothing fools. Language is as language does, not as pedants and the self-styled language police would have it do.

Of course, all languages do have internal "rules", for want of a better word, that native speakers understand without ever having to learn them. Germans don't put their verbs at the far end of a clause, or regard girls (Mädchen) as neuter or masculinity (Männlichkeit) as feminine out of perversity (at least, I don't think they do). An excellent example of an internal rule in English is the order of adjectives, something few of us will ever have given a moment's thought to, but will never have got wrong, except perhaps when drunk. The order is:

Opinion, size, age, shape, colour, origin, material, purpose (OSASCOMP)

Obviously, nobody ever really tests this order to destruction in real life (although it's fun to try), but a simple example makes the point that this is the only order that feels right and makes sense. You can say "A big black police car", but not "A police black big car". "A big police black car" is similarly awkward, but "A big police black saloon car" does make a sort of garbled sense; don't ask me how or why. IANAL, and I don't make the rules.

Let the peeving commence!

1. I was amused by comedian Chris Rock's remark that getting punched in the face by a bully at school is how you learn about tone... I certainly learned to moderate my tone at age 17, when I lost two front teeth round the back of a pub in 1971.

2. Accepting, of course, that in certain Caribbean and other dialects that might be a perfectly normal usage, and not at all "wrong".

3. People are very prone to copying such bits of prissy politesse. For example, I have completely lost patience with the fashion among people being interviewed on the radio for saying, "Good afternoon! Thank you for having me on the programme!" in reply to the first question like a well-schooled child at a birthday party, as if to say, "You, interviewer, may have no manners, but I was brought up properly"... To which the only proper response is what used to be called "an old-fashioned look".

Friday, 6 November 2026

Work in Progress


Of the 120+ photographs I had selected as candidates for the "two-squares" treatment (see the previous post Calendar Time), I noticed that quite a few of those that didn't quite work did look rather better when cropped into the whole semi-panoramic space defined by those two adjacent squares. Given the likelihood that I may put some sort of book together, it occurred to me that the two formats would sit happily alongside each other in a complementary way, perhaps even with the addition of some regular single squares, in order to enliven what would otherwise be the monotony of endless examples of the same pattern. We'll see: it's a work in progress, as they say. In the end, all I was doing originally was looking for a way to fill a calendar... 








Incidentally, those last two are actually from yet another "work in progress", in which I have been revisiting the idea of "mysterious barricades", something I first used in a little Blurb book of monochrome film photographs back in 2009 (and which I put onto Issuu as a flip book earlier this year). I explained the allusion in the book's title like this:
This series of photographs takes its name from a short keyboard piece by François Couperin (1669-1733), Les Barricades Mistérieuses. A recording by Angela Hewitt has been described as "a beautiful, undulating meditation on cycles of fifths and chord changes in B flat". No one knows what the title refers to, but I am by no means the first to borrow it, and it will resonate with anyone who has, at some time in their life, felt the frustration of unseen barriers, or encountered inexplicable or apparently pointless obstacles.
As I also had to confess, I actually first came across and appropriated that title after reading a description of the Couperin piece in William Wharton's novel Last Lovers. Bach excepted, Baroque keyboard music is quite low on my list of enthusiasms. As Sir Thomas Beecham is alleged to have remarked, the harpsichord does tend to sound like "two skeletons copulating on a tin roof". An odd comparison, really – "dancing" would surely be more apt, if less provocative? – but I suppose his multiple wives and lovers might have thought it perfectly appropriate. "Yes, that allegro vivace was thrilling, but let's make the second movement molto adagio, eh, maestro?"

William Wharton, I should say, was a very fine writer indeed whose work seems to have vanished from view. His first novel Birdy was once well-known, not least because of the film made of it by Alan Parker in 1984 and starring a very young Nicolas Cage, but if you're looking for something new to read I'd urge you to try Dad or A Midnight Clear: both outstanding books in my reckoning, FWIW.

In fact, I'm now going to do what I said I was going to do the first time I mentioned Wharton in this blog, i.e. dig them out and re-read them myself. Although finding them may well take longer than reading them... Meanwhile, here's some music:


Saturday, 31 October 2026

Calendar Time


It's around this time of year that I start thinking about what to put in a calendar for next year: essentially twelve or thirteen "landscape" A4 pages with some sort of common thread. I generally go down several rabbit holes before settling on something suitable. In past years I have even had two calendars made, one for the regular folk, and one for the cognoscenti. The numbers are never large, however, generally about twenty or so, destined for distribution, like Shakespeare's "sugared sonnets", among my "private friends". Of whom there are fewer this year; something I suppose we need to learn to accept as we find ourselves wandering into the sniper's alley of old age. As I have said before, the calendars are my way of being present and useful in the daily lives of some people – "elective family", mostly – I don't get to see often enough. Never to see or hear from some of them ever again is hard to accept, and you'd have to be rather more cynical than me to consider the savings in production costs and postage as any sort of compensation.

So, having already gone down a couple of rabbit holes – I had considered using some black and white photographs I had made twenty years ago in Mottisfont Abbey, for example (see the post Mottisfont Abbey 2006) – just this week I became obsessed by the potential of splitting a single photo over two adjacent squares. Given the right image, I found that superimposing it onto a template and playing around with the composition was both fun and rewarding. The essential idea is that one side should have a complementary or antagonistic relation with the other, while remaining obviously or subtly two sides of the same image, generally by means of some connecting line or shape. It's a bit of a "gimmick", I suppose, but I think it works.

As I say, I need a baker's dozen, but it seems that, so far, I have made 120 of them... Never mind a calendar, I now have the makings of a substantial book. So here's a little sample.






I quite like the stark, no frills approach, which would work well in a book, but for calendar purposes I'd probably do something a little more subtle and decor-friendly. This, for example:


If I do decide to go for it – there is still time for a couple more rabbit-holing excursions, after all – I will have to choose my calendrical baker's dozen out of this expanding pool of candidates: I added a few more good ones yesterday afternoon. Which is a nice problem to have, though, compared to having no idea at all of what to use this year, and a reassuring demonstration that, despite the infirmities and sorrows of age, the creative faculties are apparently still well-oiled and whirring away.

Saturday, 24 October 2026

Lost Property


The previous post's mention of Dante Gabriel Rossetti (not to mention the inescapable imminence of effin' Hallowe'en) reminded me of a notable biographical detail in the life of this solidly second-rate Victorian poet and serial painter of curiously similar-looking women. In case you were unaware of this, shall we say, unusual event, I have summarised it from Wikipedia thusly:

In 1849 or 1850, Rossetti met Elizabeth Siddal, who had entered the Pre-Raphaelite circle after being noticed by Walter Deverell while working in a milliner's in Leicester Square. Over the next decade, Siddall became Rossetti's muse and pupil, and after 1851, modelled exclusively for him. The couple were married in 1860 after a long engagement, during which Rossetti was serially unfaithful, and Siddal became addicted to laudanum. In 1862, Siddall died of an overdose of laudanum, shortly after giving birth to a stillborn child. After her death Rossetti became increasingly depressed, and when Elizabeth was buried at Highgate Cemetery, he interred the bulk of his unpublished poems with her. In later years Rossetti was prevailed upon by friends, in particular Charles Augustus Howell, to exhume his poems from his wife's grave. In 1869 he did so, collating and publishing them in 1870 in the volume Poems by D. G. Rossetti. The collection included some translations, such as his "Ballad Of Dead Ladies", an 1869 translation of François Villon's poem "Ballade des dames du temps jadis".

A number of comments suggest themselves. Let's bullet-point them:

  • Do the maths: 1862 to 1869... Eek. Enough said.
  • Surely it would have occurred to any idiot to make some copies before committing this histrionic gesture? Clearly not.
  • Before doing something even more crazy, Gabriel, you might have considered the possibility that your so-called friends might just have been winding you up. [1]
  • Laudanum... Just say no. See also absinthe.
  • "Ballad of Dead Ladies"? You're kidding, right, Gabe? What, you're Bertolt Brecht now?
  • Generally speaking, it seems best to stay well away from any involvement with poets and painters. It never seems to end well. "Scenius"? Steer clear...
I think I'm speaking for every sane person reading this blog – obviously, there are a few lunatics out there – when I say that most of us would regard any such "stuff stashed in a coffin" situation – maybe some extremely valuable keepsake or heirloom – as irreversible. Damn, I wish I hadn't done that, but what can I do about it now? Nothing, obviously. To request an exhumation – seven years later – would not (I trust) even cross your mind as a possibility. No, you'll just have to leave that Rolex for the detectorists of the future.

Which is probably why most of us are not even within shouting distance of ever achieving fame as a second- or even third-rate anything. Our names will never trouble the biographies of our more prominent contemporaries, even as a footnote to a footnote. Sane people lack the extremity of motivation that brushes off bad reviews, repeated rejection, impoverishment, personal tragedy, or any other sort of obstacle that a halfway-normal person will stand before, shrug, and say, "Oh, well! It was never meant to be. Better recalibrate and get a proper job..."

Whereas the crazy, narcissistic types simply say, "Fetch me a spade, a crowbar, a ladder, and some bolt cutters... This is very fucking far from over!"

It's in there? Not a problem, more of a challenge...

1.  A dialogue:
DGR: So I finally did what you said. I've got all those poems back now.
CAH: You did what? You mean the ones in Lizzie's grave? No way, man! Jesus H. Christ! Say you're kidding me!
DGR: No, really: they're at the dry cleaners just now, though. What a mess...
CAH: I can't believe you're serious... That's... insane...
DGR: Insane? But it was your idea! You guys kept going on about it, and I finally saw it made perfect sense!
CAH: We were winding you up, mate! We all enjoyed the look on your face whenever the subject came up, that was all...
DGR: Well, I've done it now, and I'm glad. Some of the bits I could still make out through the, uh, residue were pretty good.
CAH: What can I say, Gabe? You're a legend, mate.
In actual fact, though, it was CAH (Charles Augustus Howell ) himself who arranged the exhumation. Howell (a.k.a. "Owl") was a rogue with a reputation for blackmail, a manipulative art dealer and "business manager" who insinuated himself into the affairs of several prominent figures – Ruskin, Swinburne, and Whistler, for example – and whose life of lies and extortion and extraordinary death (go on, follow the link to Wikipedia) seem to have been rather more interesting than most. There was a biography by Helen Rossetti Angeli published in 1954 (Pre-Raphaelite Twilight, which Evelyn Waugh reviewed in The Spectator with the enticing title "A Mid-Victorian Spiv"), but I suspect a fresh, properly-researched biography is long overdue. His story would also make a cracking caper-cum-costume-drama film, with colourful touches of "body horror"... Or – here's a thought – how about a musical? The songs practically write themselves!
Mr. Rossetti
Do not forgetti
I am the man
Who's got a plan
For your sonnetti!
Yo, Lloyd-Webber, get your people to talk to my people.

Monday, 19 October 2026

October Light



                Know'st thou not at the fall of the leaf
                How the heart feels a languid grief
                Laid on it for a covering,
                And how sleep seems a goodly thing
                In Autumn at the fall of the leaf?


                And how the swift beat of the brain
                Falters because it is in vain,
                In Autumn at the fall of the leaf
                Knowest thou not? and how the chief
                Of joys seems—not to suffer pain?

                Know'st thou not at the fall of the leaf
                How the soul feels like a dried sheaf
                Bound up at length for harvesting,
                And how death seems a comely thing
                In Autumn at the fall of the leaf?

                Autumn Song, by Dante Gabriel Rossetti

Jesus Christ, Dan, ain't you got something a bit more cheery to sing? I told you to lay off that laudanum shit, it's not doing you any good at all. And what's with the "knowest thou" stuff, man? It's 1848, not 1648! Besides, that rhyme scheme is just stupid. Gimme that guitar!

Think I may have to stab him with this fork...
(Thomas Eakins, Home Ranch)

It's hard to believe that I was once signed up, full grant and all, to spend three precious youthful years, 1976-79, researching the maudlin mock-mediaeval ramblings of the so-called, self-styled Pre-Raphaelite Brotherhood. A narrow escape, and it was all really only due to one poem, "The Burden of Nineveh", as described in this post from 2010. I remember that at the time I was also convinced that Duke Luke – the name of the villain in a truly silly Rossetti poem, "The Staff and Scrip" – would make a great name for a rock band, and I see some Lithuanian dude has since made off with it. You're welcome! And no, I have never watched The Dukes of Hazzard, featuring Luke Duke, first broadcast in 1979, apparently. I wonder if the show's writers had also been reading Rossetti? Somehow I doubt it.

Psycho-Raphaelite in the V & A

Tuesday, 13 October 2026

Poster-Books



I've written about the sticky, solvent-scented joys of model-building before (e.g. see the post Regifted). Like many of us who enjoyed making models when we were kids and who may well have rediscovered that pleasure with our own children, I'm sure, I often found that contemplating a kit in its pristine, unmade state was in many ways the peak experience, a useful early lesson in the way that so many of life's keenest pleasures are as much about anticipation as fulfilment.

As a visually-oriented person, I always responded with a special interest to the ancillary design aspects of a model: the box art, the instructions with their "exploded" views, the sheet of transfers ("decals"), and so on. This was particularly the case with the sort of paper-engineering model where you have to cut out and assemble the constituent pieces, all printed on a single sheet of card alongside the instructions and other descriptive matter. It was always with a certain reluctance that I finally took up the scissors. There were cottages, castles, and theatres with a cast of cut-out characters, but the best were the life-sized versions of birds in flight made by BirdMobile which, cut out and assembled with appropriate care, were uncannily convincing, and also provided a useful early opportunity to instruct children in the safe use of sharp knives, scissors, glue, and so on.


So a few years ago, I amused myself by designing some little concertina-style booklets that imitated the look of paper engineering and could, in theory, be cut out and assembled, but were really intended as 2D wall-pieces, a sort of book in the form of a poster. Then, having admired variations on the palm-leaf book at an exhibition on Buddhism at the British Library, I started making my own "bar" books that then evolved into a style in its own right. No-one else seemed terribly turned on by these efforts, however, and that burst of cut 'n' paste creativity lapsed.

Summer grasses: /  Traces of dreams / Of ancient warriors
(Matsuo Basho)

Recently, however, Blurb have been bombarding me with special offers – never a good sign of company health, IMHO – culminating in a two-day-only "50% off + free postage" offer, which seemed too good to pass up. I had been thinking it was about time I put a new book together, so – although there are several other, but more time-consuming alternative projects waiting to be made into a book – I settled on simply putting a selection of Bars & Poster-Books into a large (30cm) square book. You can see a preview of it here in my Blurb bookstore:


Or, as usual, in the form of a much higher-quality PDF flip-book at Issuu:

It will be a great shame if the business model of Blurb is no longer working out. Each time I launch a new Blurb book into the world, it strikes me that most people – even the genial and well-informed folk who are the readers of this blog – do not understand what makes an on-demand self-publishing service different from other publishing services, and why it is such a brilliant idea. So I thought now might be a good time to repeat a few words from a previous post:

The basic Blurb model is this:
  • You sign up for an account. This costs nothing. You get a personal "bookstore" where your publicly-available books will be displayed for sale, plus various administrative tools.
  • You download some free book-making software onto your computer, BookWright, which is regularly updated. There is also an online book-creation tool for really simple stuff, or at the other extreme you can design your own complete PDF file in something like Adobe InDesign and upload it.
  • You choose a size and binding style for your book, and either use a ready-made "look", or assemble your own from page-templates which enable you to choose combinations and placement of text and image, plus essential features like page numbering.
  • You insert your text and images. Images need to be 300 dpi JPEGs or PNGs. Text can be typed in directly, cut and pasted, or uploaded from a text file. The book will sit on your own computer to be tinkered with for as long as you like.
  • When it's complete and free of errors (and you need to be very sure about that) you upload the book to Blurb.
  • To keep it there, you have to buy one copy, at basic production cost. Now, this is the point at which most people who have never tried self-publication before balk. Twenty, thirty, forty, fifty pounds? Plus postage? For one copy?? But that is not a rip-off, that is a bargain. Why?
  • Here's the thing: you yourself need never buy another copy. Repeat: you need never buy another copy.
Once it's uploaded you can invite people to buy it, privately, or open it for sale as an item listed in your personal bookstore, available in whatever formats you choose, and at the prices you decide. There are also various free tailored publicity tools available for insertion into social media, your blog or webpage, wherever. But here's the really important thing: you hold no inventory at all, and every copy that a customer buys is made on demand by Blurb, who handle the whole transaction, from payment to delivery. Any profit you have added onto the basic production cost will be passed on to you by Blurb, provided it exceeds a certain accumulated monthly total, currently £12.50. If it doesn't, it's rolled over into the next month. [1]

So your book is out there and easily available – you can even sell it on Amazon, something I have never tried – and you will not have paid a ton of money up front to a printer for a quantity of books you will never be able to distribute or sell, and which will sit unsold in boxes under your bed and in your closet, your loft, and probably also your garage forever like a bad dream. Have you ever seen a "small" run of 500 copies of a hardback book? I have (thankfully not one of mine), and you should be very afraid. Worse, if you intend to go down the classic self-publication route more than once, the only certainty is that you're going to need a bigger house. Plus a willingness to write off many thousands of pounds, all for the sake of a vanity project. [2]

The really big plus of on-demand publishers like Blurb, I think, is that the relatively low cost of entry (and the zero cost of failing to sell any copies) means that producing new books regularly is not just feasible, it is addictive. And, if you're serious about your writing, or your photography, or your recipes, or whatever it is you do, there is no better creative discipline than imagining, editing, and sequencing a book. Plus you will have a permanent, compact, and convenient record of your work, which is far more likely to survive the coming decades than boxes of prints or ephemeral image files. Best of all, it's the sort of fun, self-motivating challenge that can shift your work into a higher gear.

But you should never imagine that you might sell more than, say, 10 copies. Dream on! Also, although their stats will tell you how many copies of your books have been sold in the last 45 days (none at all, usually), Blurb will not disclose the name, email, or location of anyone who does buy a copy, so gratitude from you, the author, to your tiny group of fans has to be taken for granted. But then, Lee Child doesn't send a thank-you note to everyone who buys his books, so why should you?

So who is this "Mike Chisholm", anyway?

1. I suspect that a significant flaw in the Blurb model, from a profitability p-o-v, is that (a) few people who make Blurb books are interested in buying the books of other Blurb users, and (b) habitual book buyers are unlikely to be looking at Blurb as a primary source. I'm pretty generous in my own book-buying, but have only ever bought four Blurb books other than my own.

2. The dirty secret of "real" photo-book publishing is that you will be expected by the publisher to cover anything between 50% and 100% of the cost of publication. Sure, your book will get a certain amount of publicity and distribution, but sales and profits will still be low. It's really just a way of taking vanity to the next level.

Wednesday, 7 October 2026

Classic

 Now that I've been writing these blog posts for a while – 18 years, actually, which is rather more than "a while" – there are quite a few that, if I were to write them now, I might well do differently. I've learned a lot about myself and my views by thinking about me and them out loud in public, as it were, and no doubt my ability to write has improved along the way, too. So at moments like this, in a (hopefully brief) post-viral lassitude when fresh subject matter seems elusive, I find it a useful exercise to excavate posts that are more than a few years old and polish them up to 2026 specifications.


This one is a substantially revised version of something I first posted in 2016, and which was subsequently published in the online magazine "On Landscape", where it kicked up a certain amount of unrest (no, that's not a misspelling of "interest"), even provoking a written response from Mr. Landscape himself, Joe Cornish. [1] Well, you just know when you're doing something right... I don't think my views have changed much, but they have softened, and I do think I can make a better job now of expressing them. So here we go.

Southampton Mayflower Park Pier

So let's say I'm reading the review section of the Guardian newspaper one Saturday and above a review of Yuki Chan in Brontë Country, a novel by Mick Jackson, there's a photograph of what I suppose has to be the North York Moors, given the context. Even printed small on newsprint it's striking: a long vista over a craggy moor, alive with the russet and green tones of moorland in scudding sunlight. You can practically feel the wind tugging at your clothing. In the mid-distance there's a crag that could be a house, or a house that could be a crag. So I look to see who the photographer is; to do this I have to turn the paper sideways and squint at the tiny picture credit at the bottom right-hand edge of the page. It reads ALAMY. Nothing else. It seems this beautiful image has been sourced, merely for illustrative purposes, uncredited from a stock photo agency.

Later, looking through Landmark, an intelligent and interesting anthology of contemporary landscape work compiled by William A. Ewing (Thames & Hudson, 2014), I found myself wondering: is landscape photography over, finished with, exhausted?

In one sense, clearly not: more and more people are producing more and more landscape photographs, and this major photographic genre has also become an important ancillary to other activities, such as walking, climbing, travelling, and even the pursuit of spirituality and mental health. But... Sheer populousness is generally a sign that something has peaked, and that its exciting, pioneering days are over. Now that it has become necessary to arrange an orderly queue to the summit of Everest, you can be forgiven for suspecting that the challenge is not quite what once it was.

Once doubts had begun to creep in, other questions followed. Given how varied the world is, and how different people are, I asked myself: why do so many landscape photographs look exactly the same? And why are they so unregarded? To the extent that they can be bought by the yard from an agency, and published uncredited as decorative filler in a newspaper?

Southampton Mayflower Park

There is no denying that landscape photography has become very popular, of  course; both to do, and to look at. I would think no other self-consciously "artistic" genre of photography is so widespread, with the exceptions of fashion and food. Since the advent of digital colour, there has been a tsunami / avalanche / deluge / (pick your own landscape-related simile) of outstanding landscape images of every conceivable kind. From the highest, snowiest peaks to the grimmest, most litter-strewn edgelands, someone will have parked a high-resolution camera on a tripod and composed something that is, for however brief a moment, compellingly new.

Brief, because originality is inevitably followed by hundreds of "me too" imitators, few of whom will have improved on the pioneering work, a cycle of discovery and repetition that is repeated again and again until pretty much every accessible landscape has been photographed many times over, at every time of day, in every kind of weather, leading to a queasy sense of repletion. I mean, just enter "skye storr" into Google, and scroll through the images. Depressing, isn't it? Travel has become cheap and easy, the world is finite, and so are the places to stand and admire its beauty. Even the relatively recent novelty of aerial drone photography has worn pretty thin surprisingly quickly; it has already become just the same-old same-old, following that same cycle of discovery and copy-cat repetition ad nauseam.

When it comes to art, democratic inclusiveness has never really been a useful evaluative benchmark. Art is an essentially elitist pursuit. Or rather, it is when it comes to art as outcome. If instead we choose to regard art-making as an activity which, regardless of the quality of the outcome, is capable of refining and advancing our aesthetic, social, and spiritual instincts and impulses, then clearly it's something which as many people as possible should be encouraged to do. Yes, get out there with your brushes, paints, cameras, sketchbooks, whatever turns you on, and just do it, in the same participative spirit that animates sport and exercise, whereby millions do yoga or zumba, play football or tennis, walk, cycle, and jog; why, you can even train for a marathon if you're the goal-oriented sort. Of course! But the gold standard of anything is always about outcome. Of 60,000 participants, who will actually win the London Marathon? Will they have broken a record?

Bristol Sea Mills after flooding

So how has the predictable same-old-sameness of what has come to count as "gold standard" landscape photography come about? For a start, I don't think it's a false impression that very many, if not most landscape photographers seem to share an identity: male, middle-aged, bearded, a bit weather-beaten and scruffy, and fond of solitary pursuits. But then, these do tend to be the sort of people who find themselves out in the world at dawn or at dusk, having endured rain and cold or heat and thirst to lug many pounds of expensive kit into the wilderness, just for the prospect of a decent photograph. Plus, in what is still a very "gendered" world, landscape photography is one of few outlets for masculine self-expression that combines nicely with physical engagement with the outdoors and that very male obsession with gear and craft. In the end, although there are many people who like to look at landscape photographs – they do make a nice calendar – there are far fewer who are prepared to go out there and get actual landscape all over their shoes and clothes in order to make them.

So perhaps landscape photographs look so similar simply because the people making them are so similar? Might encouraging more, different demographics to want to get "out there" make a difference? Would they end up in different places, with different gear, and with a different point of view? It's certainly a thought. But that initial desire to go out and play in the wind, rain, and mud is both a crucial motivating factor and the main barrier to entry, obviously. Provided, of course, that your definition of "landscape" is restricted to picturesque and remote semi-wilderness. Other vistas are available.

One way to get past the saturation point of sameness is gimmickry. Some landscapists have managed to break free of photo-purist objections to digital manipulation, as well as the slightly bonkers obsession with sunrises and sunsets, and various other hidebound "camera club" traditions relating to landscape photography; the exclusive use of wide-angle lenses, for example. But these newer approaches still have a tendency to converge on well-worn paths, on certain "looks". On a visit to our local hospital I was struck by a row of impressionistic landscape prints running down one corridor. These are now quite old – probably lithographs made in the 1980s – but they have more than a slight resemblance to a lot of "new" landscape photography being done, for example, with the use of overlaid texture layers in Photoshop, or in-camera effects like multiple exposures or ICM ("intentional camera movement", a name I always find hilarious). Scratchy, spattered, blotchy, blurry, painterly: these are well-established clichés of art-school print-making, and no less of a cliché when achieved by new means or arrived at by a different evolutionary pictorial path. As with the law, ignorance of art history is no excuse if your ambition is to be taken seriously as an artist. Too many photographers only follow photography.

Southampton Common, Cemetery Lake

Sadly, getting somewhere new in picture-making is even harder than finding somewhere new in the landscape to photograph, and really has everything to do with developing a strong personal sensibility and very little to do with technique. You can joggle your camera all you like, but it is no substitute for the unique choices made by a visually-educated eye. Typically, landscape photography – despite the way it attracts the word "romantic" to itself – is actually rather classical at heart, in the sense that it is largely about the imitation of established models and masters, and thus has a tendency to produce "school of" works. It never ceases to amaze me, for example, how many Michael Kenna tribute acts there are at work out there, shamelessly reproducing his signature moves with long exposures, trees, fences, and snow. Hey, what's the big deal? I can do that, too! (Yes, you can, now...).

Like 19th century academic painting, conventional gold-standard landscape photography is polished, highly-wrought, rather rule-bound, and suffused by a strong tendency to idealize. A truly dedicated landscape photographer doesn't simply document what happened to be there when they happened to be there, the way you or I might, but studies the times of sunrise and moonrise, waits for the right weather and time of day, and thinks nothing of revisiting the same remote site on multiple occasions until conditions are just right. Just right, that is, to invest a photograph of a landscape with certain supplementary properties, which can be summed up with one word: wow. But, inevitably, photographs of such rarely-observed syzygies in which all the elements are in perfectly picturesque alignment are by definition a freak, a distortion of reality, especially when amplifed by a taste for over-saturated colours and apocalyptic skies.

Have another look at those images of the Old Man of Storr, for example: exactly what planet were they made on? Clearly, there is a landscape photography "look" that is rather different from the appearance of any actual landscape, and it is this look that wannabe landscape photographers aspire to, not least because it wins competitions; even ones that claim to be looking beyond the usual overcooked clichés, like the Natural Landscape Photography Awards. I discussed this at length in my post about the results of the first NLPA competition in 2021 (Extreme Locations & Iconic Conditions), so I won't repeat what I wrote there, other than to say this: "An unfortunate side-effect of all competitions is that the virtues perceived and admired by the judges in their chosen winners tend to be noted and imitated by the thousands of aspirants seeking the validation of a competition win, or in pursuit of more social media 'likes'. Hey, look, I can do that, too!". (Yes, you can, now...).

Southampton Holyrood Church

Then there is that question of the lack of regard for and the disposability of landscape photographs, as exemplified by their uncredited use as illustrative filler in a newspaper review. Need an illustration of "Brontë Country"? A search on the stock photo agency Alamy for "bronte country" yields over 5,000 images; "north york moors" 25,000. Phew... But that one there will do nicely; no, it doesn't matter who made it, just pay the fee and credit the agency. I'm reminded of the discovery of Japanese woodblock prints by European artists in the 19th century, little enough regarded in Japan that they were used as packing in crates of exported porcelain. In Europe it didn't matter that the individual signatures couldn't be read, and a Hiroshige print distinguished from one by Hokusai; what mattered was that exciting "japoniste" look they shared, and which offered a stimulating way forward from the conventions of academic painting.

Of course, the pursuit of originality of vision, individual renown, exhibitions, and publication is an inherently quixotic enterprise, these being goals that few are ever likely to achieve, especially using an essentially anonymous technique like photography in a field as overpopulated as landscape. Besides, an imitative classicism does have its own well-defined, achievable satisfactions and, like running the London Marathon, the training, the participation, and the receipt of the equivalent of a "finisher's" medal – having your work accepted into a stock photo agency, perhaps? – can be reward enough. Ten years of innocence and experience on from my original combative post, I feel less inclined to be dismissive of such realisable ambitions.

In the end, it's no surprise that one competent photographer's rendering of classic subject matter in the classic landscape photography manner – whether it be (yawn) a stand of receding birch-tree trunks, or the Old Man of Storr, or Tuscan hillsides in raking sunlight, or Provençal lavender fields, or (zzzz) autumn leaves, or mountain tops catching the sunrise, etc., etc. – will be pretty indistinguishable from any other's. For all the effort that will have gone into getting the shot, however spectacular and hard-won, the result is generally just one more ephemeral, calendar-quality piece of eye-candy, a picture that has little to say beyond bearing witness to the undeniable fact that – despite humanity's best efforts to trash the place, and nature's escalating attempts to burn us out – in certain combinations of lighting, weather, and time of day some parts of the world can still be very beautiful indeed. In a word: wow. The photographer – whose name you may never even discover – has spared you the effort of trekking out there yourself, and the probable disappointment of seeing the place in a less than flattering light.

Something which, as I say, I'm less inclined to disparage today than I was a decade ago. I'm probably still incurably quixotico-romantic in outlook, but perhaps the older Goethe wasn't so far off the mark when he declared "I call the classical health and the romantic sickness" (Conversations with Eckermann, April 2 1829), although I think what he really meant was that he called the healthy classical, and the sickly romantic. Whatever, I doubt that he had envisioned that the end purpose of a "healthy" strategy would be to dump one's lookalike work into a tank into which anyone could dip their bucket for a small fee, or indeed one in which AI could splash about "training" itself, absolutely free of charge.

So, to return to my original question: is landscape photography over, finished with, exhausted? No, not yet, but like me it is very tired, and could do with a holiday and a change of scene...

Winchester, bridge near Hockley Viaduct

1. A joke I was once told:

A: You know what would improve that landscape shot?
B: No, what?
A: A JCB in the foreground...
B: What, a big yellow digger? Are you mad?
A: No, not a digger, a Joe Cornish Boulder.

Needless to say, I had removed this joke from the version published in "On Landscape"...